Europe car scrapping seen failing green test
Tuesday, June 9th, 2009OSLO (Reuters June 9, 2009) - European car scrapping schemes are aiding a shift to small, less polluting cars but environmental campaigners say they fall short of pledges to create a greener economy during the recession.
“It’s definitely a missed opportunity. This is just doling out cash to the car industry,” said Jos Dings, director of the European Federation for Transport and Environment, which campaigns for greener transport.
“The first goal is to help the economy,” German Environment Minister Sigmar Gabriel said of a “cash for clunkers” subsidy that helped boost German car sales by 40 percent in May from the same 2008 month.
“The indirect effect is that you help the climate” by replacing old cars with cleaner vehicles, the minister told Reuters of the scheme that pays motorists 2,500 euros ($3,468) to scrap a car at least nine years old and buy a new vehicle.
Countries setting no demands for low carbon vehicles “have the approach that new cars are better than old ones,” European Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas told Reuters.
But he said he felt it would be “even better” for governments to spell out tough carbon standards.
“Small cars are benefiting most,” said Sigrid de Vries, spokeswoman of ACEA. “It’s simply not right to say that there is no environmental benefit.”
But Dings noted that German motorists can in theory scrap an aging gasoline-sipping Volkswagen Lupo and use a 2,500 euro subsidy to buy a Porsche Cayenne sport utility vehicle.
ZED COMMENT: With the hydrogen fueled ZED engine, a motorist can purchase any vehicle they wish and not worry about pollution because regardless of engine size, the ZED engine emits only water vapor. With no chassis redesign needed, the ZED engine can readily replace any gasoline or diesel engine in any vehicle without major reconfiguration. With a projected cost of production less than gasoline, no government subsidy is required.