Study Raises Cost Estimate for Electric Cars
Thursday, January 14th, 2010New York Times January 7, 2010. DETROIT — As General Motors began assembling batteries for the coming Chevrolet Volt on Thursday, a new study cast doubt on the likelihood that electric cars will be widely popular in the near future.
The study, conducted by the Boston Consulting Group, said battery costs were not expected to fall as much as automakers have projected, making electric vehicles too expensive for most consumers even 10 years from now.
The firm predicted that electric cars would account for just 6 percent of the global market in 2020, or about three million of an estimated 54.5 million vehicles sold over all.
The energy secretary, Steven Chu, said the vehicles were critical to helping Detroit’s automakers become successful again.
“We urgently need to change how we power our cars and trucks,” Mr. Chu said. “America has fallen behind in the race to build cars of the future.”
The Boston Consulting Group study, however, forecasts that most gasoline-powered cars will remain most popular for many years. It forecasts that they will represent 62 percent of sales in the United States and 58 percent of sales worldwide in 2020.
The main factor, the study says, is price. It predicts that the cost of a battery pack about the size of the Volt’s will fall by $10,000, or 64 percent, from 2009 to 2020. But even then it would take about 15 years for the cost of owning an electric vehicle to equal that of a gas-powered car.
“We’re going to show those foreigners how you make cars, and we’re going to have success,” Representative John D. Dingell, Democrat of Michigan, said.
ZED COMMENT: Show those foreigners how to make cars? VW, the worlds largest manufacturer, recently declared the electric car “hype”. Mitsubishi predicts a Lithium shortage by 2015 and a sharp increase in price. The BBC asks if we are trading Saudi oil for Bolivian Lithium, an unfriendly country which holds 80% of the world’s reserves. If it takes 15 years for electric to reach (not exceed) the same operating cost as gasoline, and the average USA car is 12 years old, most electrics will be scrapped before they become financially viable. Alternately, ZED engines are built from 100% recyclable materials on current assembly lines using current processes, at a cost 1/3 less than conventional engines. When fueled by hydrogen the ZED engine is more powerful than electric, has a significantly greater range in any application and has zero emissions. Respectfully, Mr. Chu has identified the problem, but not the answer.